Aegis General faces lawsuit as rivals allege executive poaching, trade secrets theft

Filed on August 8, 2025, in the US District Court for the Middle District of Pennsylvania, the complaint lays out a scenario that will sound familiar to many in the insurance sector. Millennial alleges that four of its senior Scale Underwriting employees – Jeffrey Hirsch, Matthew McKenna, Juliana Rosas Litourgis, and Leanna Marciano – resigned together in June 2024 and joined Aegis General Insurance Agency, a subsidiary of K2 Insurance Services. According to Millennial, these departures were not just routine turnover, but a coordinated move that gave Aegis a shortcut into the specialty insurance market.